DitchCable.ai LogoDitchCable.ai

← Back to Guides

network-tuner
hdhomerun
tablo
cord-cutting
dvr

HDHomeRun vs Tablo: Which Network Tuner is Right for You?

Compare HDHomeRun and Tablo network tuners for cord-cutting. Features, pricing, DVR options, and which one is best for your needs.

HDHomeRun vs Tablo: Which Network Tuner is Right for You?

Last Updated: October 2025

If you're cutting cable, you've probably heard about network tuners. These devices let you watch antenna TV on any device in your home without running coaxial cables to every room. But choosing between HDHomeRun and Tablo can be confusing.

This guide breaks down the differences, features, and which option is best for your situation.

What is a Network Tuner and Why You Need One

A network tuner connects your TV antenna to your home network (WiFi or Ethernet). Instead of running coax cables to every TV, you plug the network tuner into your router. Then any streaming device connected to your network can watch live antenna TV.

The traditional setup: Antenna → 50ft coax cable → Living Room TV Antenna → 75ft coax cable → Bedroom TV Antenna → 100ft coax cable → Basement TV

The network tuner setup: Antenna → Network Tuner → Router → All TVs wirelessly

Benefits of network tuners:

  • Watch live antenna TV on any device (smart TVs, phones, tablets, streaming devices)
  • No coax cables running through your walls
  • Multiple people can watch different channels simultaneously
  • Built-in or add-on DVR functionality
  • Pause, rewind, and record live TV
  • Works with devices you already own

HDHomeRun Lineup

SiliconDust makes HDHomeRun devices, which have been the gold standard for network tuners since 2007.

HDHomeRun Flex Duo (2 Tuners)

  • Price: $149.99
  • Amazon Link: HDHomeRun Flex Duo
  • Tuners: 2 (watch/record 2 channels simultaneously)
  • DVR: No built-in storage (requires separate software/storage)
  • Best For: 1-2 person households, light TV watchers

The Flex Duo is the budget-friendly HDHomeRun option. With 2 tuners, two people can watch different channels at the same time, or you can watch one channel while recording another.

Pros:

  • Most affordable HDHomeRun option
  • Small, compact design
  • Easy setup

Cons:

  • Only 2 tuners (can be limiting for larger families)
  • No built-in DVR (requires Channels DVR or Plex Pass)

HDHomeRun Flex 4K (4 Tuners) - Our Top Pick

  • Price: $199.99
  • Amazon Link: HDHomeRun Flex 4K
  • Tuners: 4 (watch/record 4 channels simultaneously)
  • DVR: No built-in storage (requires separate software/storage)
  • Best For: Most cord-cutters, families with 3+ TVs

The Flex 4K is the sweet spot for most people. Four tuners means your family can watch different channels in multiple rooms while the DVR records other shows in the background.

Pros:

  • 4 tuners handle most household needs
  • ATSC 3.0 (NextGen TV) support for future 4K broadcasts
  • Works with every streaming platform
  • Excellent app ecosystem
  • Best performance and reliability

Cons:

  • No built-in DVR storage
  • Slightly more expensive than Flex Duo

HDHomeRun Scribe Duo (2 Tuners + Built-in DVR)

  • Price: $229.99
  • Amazon Link: HDHomeRun Scribe Duo
  • Tuners: 2
  • DVR: 150GB internal storage (~80 hours HD recording)
  • Best For: People who want simple, all-in-one DVR

The Scribe Duo includes built-in DVR functionality and 150GB of storage. No subscription required, no external hard drive needed.

Pros:

  • Built-in DVR with no monthly fees
  • Simple setup (no additional software)
  • 150GB storage included

Cons:

  • Only 2 tuners
  • Limited storage (150GB = ~80 hours HD)
  • More expensive than Flex Duo
  • DVR features not as robust as Channels or Plex

Tablo Lineup

Nuvyyo makes Tablo devices, which are all-in-one network tuners with built-in DVR functionality.

Tablo Dual HDMI (2 Tuners + DVR)

  • Price: $249.99
  • Amazon Link: Tablo Dual HDMI
  • Tuners: 2
  • DVR: Requires USB storage (not included)
  • HDMI Output: Yes (can connect directly to TV)
  • Best For: Single TV households who want DVR

The Tablo Dual HDMI is unique because it has an HDMI output. You can connect it directly to your TV like a traditional DVR, or use it as a network tuner for other devices.

Pros:

  • HDMI output for direct TV connection
  • Works as traditional DVR without network
  • Built-in program guide
  • Commercial skip feature

Cons:

  • Only 2 tuners
  • Requires USB storage for DVR
  • Less streaming device support than HDHomeRun

Tablo Quad HDMI (4 Tuners + DVR)

  • Price: $299.99
  • Amazon Link: Tablo Quad HDMI
  • Tuners: 4
  • DVR: Requires USB storage (not included)
  • HDMI Output: Yes
  • Best For: Families who want all-in-one DVR solution

The Quad HDMI adds two more tuners for larger families. Like the Dual, it can connect directly to your TV or work as a network device.

Pros:

  • 4 tuners for multi-room recording
  • HDMI for traditional use
  • Comprehensive DVR features
  • Commercial skip

Cons:

  • Most expensive option ($299.99)
  • Still requires USB storage
  • DVR requires active internet connection

Feature Comparison

| Feature | HDHomeRun Flex 4K | Tablo Quad HDMI | |---------|-------------------|-----------------| | Price | $199.99 | $299.99 | | Tuners | 4 | 4 | | Built-in DVR | No | Yes | | Storage | External (optional) | USB (required) | | Monthly Fee | No | No | | DVR Software Options | Channels, Plex, others | Built-in only | | ATSC 3.0 Support | Yes | No | | Streaming Devices | All major platforms | Limited support | | Commercial Skip | Via Channels DVR | Built-in | | Program Guide | Via apps | Built-in | | HDMI Output | No | Yes | | Mobile Streaming | Yes | Yes | | Internet Required | No (local only) | Yes (for DVR) |

Streaming Device Compatibility

HDHomeRun Works With:

  • Apple TV (best experience)
  • Roku
  • Amazon Fire TV
  • Android TV / Google TV
  • iOS / iPad
  • Android phones/tablets
  • Windows / Mac / Linux
  • Web browsers
  • Plex (with Plex Pass)
  • Channels DVR
  • Emby
  • Kodi

Winner: HDHomeRun has universal support across all platforms.

Tablo Works With:

  • Roku
  • Amazon Fire TV
  • Android TV / Google TV
  • iOS / iPad (limited)
  • Android phones/tablets
  • Web browsers

Note: Tablo's Apple TV app is not as fully-featured as HDHomeRun's, and some smart TV platforms lack native apps.

DVR Software Options

HDHomeRun DVR Solutions

HDHomeRun requires third-party DVR software, which gives you flexibility but adds complexity:

Option 1: Channels DVR (Our Recommendation)

  • Cost: $79.99/year or $239.99 one-time
  • Link: Channels DVR
  • Best DVR experience available
  • Automatic commercial skip
  • Beautiful interface
  • Works on all streaming devices
  • Requires dedicated computer or NAS

Option 2: Plex Pass

  • Cost: $4.99/month or $119.99 lifetime
  • Integrates with your media library
  • Good DVR features
  • Commercial skip
  • Requires Plex Media Server

Option 3: HDHomeRun Scribe (All-in-One)

  • Cost: $229.99 (hardware only)
  • Built-in basic DVR
  • 150GB storage
  • No additional software needed

Storage Needed:

Recording Capacity:

  • 1TB = 500 hours of HD content
  • 2TB = 1,000 hours (~40 days of continuous recording)
  • 4TB = 2,000 hours (~80 days)

Tablo DVR Solution

Tablo includes built-in DVR software, but requires USB storage:

  • Built-in program guide (free)
  • Automatic recordings
  • Commercial skip (premium feature)
  • Series management
  • Scheduled recordings
  • Internet required for full functionality

Storage Needed (same as HDHomeRun):

Setup Comparison

HDHomeRun Setup (Flex 4K Example)

  1. Connect antenna to HDHomeRun via coax cable
  2. Connect HDHomeRun to router via ethernet cable
  3. Power on HDHomeRun
  4. Download HDHomeRun app on streaming device
  5. Scan for channels
  6. Start watching

For DVR: 7. Install Channels DVR on computer/NAS 8. Connect external hard drive 9. Configure recording settings

Total Time: 15 minutes for basic setup, 45 minutes for DVR

Tablo Setup

  1. Connect antenna to Tablo via coax cable
  2. Connect Tablo to router via ethernet (or WiFi)
  3. Connect USB hard drive for DVR
  4. Power on Tablo
  5. Open Tablo app on streaming device
  6. Follow setup wizard
  7. Scan for channels
  8. Configure recording settings

Total Time: 30 minutes including DVR

Winner: HDHomeRun is faster for basic setup. Tablo takes slightly longer but DVR is integrated.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose HDHomeRun Flex 4K If:

  • You want the most flexibility and device compatibility
  • You already use or plan to use Apple TV, Roku, or other streaming devices
  • You want the best possible streaming quality and reliability
  • You're willing to set up Channels DVR or Plex for advanced DVR features
  • You want ATSC 3.0 (future 4K) support
  • You prefer a modular system you can customize

Best Setup for HDHomeRun:

Choose Tablo Quad HDMI If:

  • You want an all-in-one DVR solution without additional software
  • You prefer connecting directly to your TV via HDMI like a traditional DVR
  • You primarily use Roku or Fire TV streaming devices
  • You want commercial skip built-in
  • You prefer simplicity over flexibility

Best Setup for Tablo:

Our Recommendation

For most cord-cutters, we recommend the HDHomeRun Flex 4K.

Here's why:

  • Better streaming device compatibility (especially Apple TV)
  • ATSC 3.0 support for future 4K broadcasts
  • More reliable streaming quality
  • Flexibility to choose your DVR software
  • Works perfectly without internet connection
  • Industry-leading support and updates

The best overall setup:

  1. HDHomeRun Flex 4K ($199.99)
  2. Apple TV 4K 128GB ($149.99 per TV)
  3. Channels DVR subscription ($79.99/year)
  4. WD Elements 4TB for storage ($89.99)

This combination provides the best user experience, reliability, and features. Total investment: ~$520 for one TV, plus $150 for each additional TV.

For budget-conscious shoppers or those who want simplicity:

Go with the HDHomeRun Flex Duo ($149.99) paired with Roku Streaming Stick 4K ($49.99) for basic live TV without DVR. Total: $200.

Complete Shopping List

Premium HDHomeRun Setup (Recommended)

Budget HDHomeRun Setup

All-in-One Tablo Setup

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Do I need internet for HDHomeRun or Tablo? A: HDHomeRun works completely offline for live TV and local DVR playback. Tablo requires internet for DVR functionality and program guide updates.

Q: Can I watch on multiple TVs at once? A: Yes, but you're limited by the number of tuners. A 4-tuner device allows 4 simultaneous streams. If someone is recording, that uses a tuner too.

Q: What if I run out of DVR storage? A: For HDHomeRun with external storage or Tablo, you can upgrade to a larger USB hard drive anytime. The Scribe Duo is limited to its built-in 150GB.

Q: Can I watch recordings outside my home? A: Yes, both HDHomeRun and Tablo support remote viewing over the internet. Channels DVR also supports remote access.

Q: Do these work with my existing antenna? A: Yes! Any TV antenna works with both HDHomeRun and Tablo. Just connect the coax cable from your antenna to the network tuner.

Q: Which has better picture quality? A: Both deliver the same quality from your antenna. The streaming quality depends on your home network. HDHomeRun generally has better streaming performance on Apple TV.

Next Steps

Ready to set up your network tuner? Here's what you need:

  1. Choose your network tuner based on your needs and budget
  2. Get a good antenna if you don't have one yet (see our antenna guide)
  3. Pick streaming devices for each TV (Apple TV 4K works best with HDHomeRun)
  4. Add storage if you want DVR functionality (4TB drive recommended)
  5. Connect everything - antenna to tuner, tuner to router, install apps
  6. Scan for channels and start watching free TV!

The whole process takes about 30 minutes, and you'll be watching free HD TV on every device in your home.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission from purchases made through links on this page at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products we've personally tested or thoroughly researched.

Get Your Personalized Cord-Cutting Plan

See exactly what equipment you need, which channels you'll get, and how much you'll save

Get Started Free
← Back to All Guides